Skip to content
No. 026On holdSoil, groundwater and fisheriesUpdated Nov 15, 2026

Working out how much of the fall in Lake Kariba's kapenta catch (a cheap sardine-like fish eaten by poor households in Zambia and Zimbabwe) is caused by a warming lake and how much by too many fishing rigs, so that managers know whether cutting the number of rigs would bring the catch back

Good it would do
3 / 5
Can AI help
2 / 5
How neglected
4 / 5
Can we check it
3 / 5

Why it's on hold

Parked: the climate-versus-rigs dispute over Kariba's kapenta is real and no fitted joint model exists, but the public catch-effort series ends in 2011, its effort is partly back-calculated from catch, unrecorded catch may be as large as recorded, and satellite overlap is about five years, so the split is weakly identified and managers have already set a 500-rig limit.

Why it's stuck

Scientists disagree, and nobody has tested both explanations in one model on the same data. A presentation on Lake Kariba hosted on the UN climate body's website (undated in the extracted text) says fishing effort fell by about half, "so overfishing ruled out as influential factor on fish production", and that kapenta catch per unit of effort "corresponds strongly with climatic variables: rainfall, air temperature and lake water levels" (unfccc.int, 5_mzime.pdf, page 7).

What we'd try

Build a stock model of the kapenta population that includes both fishing effort and lake conditions (surface temperature, water level, and plankton food), and fit it to catch and effort records with careful accounting for uncertainty, for example a Bayesian state-space model run many thousands of times. Lake conditions could come from the ESA Lakes Climate Change Initiative, a public satellite record of lake surface temperature, water extent and water colour for over 2000 large lakes from 1992 to 2020.

We'd look again if

All three: (1) a simulation-recovery check on the public 1982-2011 series, including reporting error, shows which extra records would narrow the climate/effort split to a useful range; (2) those records become available, e.g. an aggregated lake-wide monthly catch and nights-fished series for 2012 to now, or an independent effort record (rig census or vessel-monitoring data); (3) the Zambia-Zimbabwe Technical Committee, ZimParks or Zambia's Department of Fisheries names a decision the attribution would change.

Source: https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/5_mzime.pdf

Think we got it wrong?

Ruled-out problems can come back. Tell us what we missed.

Members can read the full record for this problem, check its sources and comment. Open the member view →