Did the published forecasts of where the invasive urban malaria mosquito Anopheles stephensi would spread in Africa (the 2020 habitat map by Sinka and colleagues, and the 2021 shipping-trade ranking by Ahn and colleagues) actually predict the countries and cities where it was found afterwards, and can a model that passes that test say where surveillance should look next?
- Good it would do
- 2 / 5
- Can AI help
- 3 / 5
- How neglected
- 3 / 5
- Can we check it
- 3 / 5
Why it's on hold
Park. The harm is real and nobody has published a reproducible score of either forecast, but UC Irvine already scored Sinka's map for the Horn (NIH-funded), a Wellcome-funded consortium already optimises surveillance sites within Djibouti, Ethiopia and Kenya, the shipping ranking has only two later outcomes in scope (Ghana, Kenya), discovery dates lag arrival, Sinka's 2020 map is not public, and a new where-to-look ranking can only be proven by field surveys.
Why it's stuck
The forecasts were published and used to argue for surveillance, but the searches in this run found no study that scores them against the detections that came later. That check only became possible recently, as detections piled up.
What we'd try
Download the WHO Malaria Threats Map invasive-species records (WHO says 'A download tool allows users to download data for their own analysis') and the GBIF occurrence dataset for An. stephensi from 1985 to 2019. First, score the two published forecasts against detections made after they appeared: hits, misses and ranking skill, compared with simple baselines (distance to the nearest known site, port traffic, city size).
We'd look again if
Both: (1) Sinka's 2020 prediction map is obtained from its authors and a dated ledger (first collection, confirmation, survey coverage) built from WHO's Not-found surveys and Sedda's open zero catches shows enough independent, comparably surveyed outcomes for a held-out test with meaningful uncertainty; (2) WHO, a national malaria programme, PMI or the Wellcome-funded consortium says an independent score of these forecasts would change where it surveys next.
Source: https://researchonline.lshtm.ac.uk/4673526/1/Taylor-etal-Invasive-Anopheles-stephensi-in-Africa.pdf
Think we got it wrong?
Ruled-out problems can come back. Tell us what we missed.
Members can read the full record for this problem, check its sources and comment. Open the member view → Not a member? Here is how to join.