What killed the migrating songbirds that died across the US Southwest in August and September 2020: starvation after drought, the 8–9 September cold storm, wildfire smoke, or these acting together?
- Good it would do
- 2 / 5
- Can AI help
- 3 / 5
- How neglected
- 4 / 5
- Can we check it
- 3 / 5
Why it's on hold
A real, unsolved mystery with public data, but the only test the lab could run now, on iNaturalist dead-bird photos, cannot yet tell extra deaths from extra looking: the collection project and national news began with the 8-9 September storm, and drought covered nearly all of New Mexico. Both outside critics rated the proposed test fatally flawed, so Checkable drops to 3, below the mystery bar of 4.
Why it's stuck
The papers that exist disagree and none weighs the suspects against each other. Yang et al.
What we'd try
Suspects and what each predicts. (1) Drought starvation: deaths begin before the storm, are concentrated in insect-eaters, and scale with drought severity along the migration route, not with smoke.
We'd look again if
Any one of: (1) an independent mortality record with documented search effort before and after 8 Sept 2020 becomes usable (the NMSU Digital Commons carcass file, fetched by a person, gives dates, places and effort; or the wildlife mortality database with 'nearly 10,000' reports is found and shareable at county level); (2) an approved small feasibility check shows the excess survives plausible targeted reporting and the analysis can exclude a meaningful smoke or drought effect; (3) an expert confirms a public contrast separating drought-weakened birds killed by cold from cold alone.
Source: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2026.1763394/full
Think we got it wrong?
Ruled-out problems can come back. Tell us what we missed.
Members can read the full record for this problem, check its sources and comment. Open the member view → Not a member? Here is how to join.